| anthropology site | site map | bbs | contact | site news | |

American Anthropological Association opposes collaboration with the military

2007-11-16

American Anthropological Association opposes collaboration with the military

applied anthropology, anthropology (general), ethics
American Anthropological Association opposes collaboration with the military
A few days ago, the Executive Board of the American Anthropological Association (AAA) opposed the embedding of anthropologists in military teams (HTS) in Iraq and Afghanistan. The use of anthropological knowledge in the U.S. military and the militarisation of anthropology has been the most discussed topic among anthropologists this year.

We read:
The Executive Board of the American Anthropological Association concludes (i) that the HTS program creates conditions which are likely to place anthropologists in positions in which their work will be in violation of the AAA Code of Ethics and (ii) that its use of anthropologists poses a danger to both other anthropologists and persons other anthropologists study.
Thus the Executive Board expresses its disapproval of the HTS program.
In the context of a war that is widely recognized as a denial of human rights and based on faulty intelligence and undemocratic principles, the Executive Board sees the HTS project as a problematic application of anthropological expertise, most specifically on ethical grounds. We have grave concerns about the involvement of anthropological knowledge and skill in the HTS project. The Executive Board views the HTS project as an unacceptable application of anthropological expertise.
To facilitate discussion on this subject, the AAA has created this blog as a forum for members to post comments regarding the Executive Board statement and related issues. Currently, their first and only blog post about the Board statement has 64 comments!
It was fascinating to see how quickly the anthropological blogosphere reacted. Short time after the publication of the statement, the first blog posts appeared:
L.L. Wynn at Culture Matters summarizes the statement and the first reactions.

Alex Golub, Savage Minds sounds enthusiastic:
The statement clearly (in my humble opinion) shows the influence of SM (Savage Minds) and the anthropological noosphere more generally on the AAA exec board and every reader, commenter and Mind should be proud to see that this is really a case of our community forming a ‘civil sphere’ that can inform AAA decision making.
I am blown away by the quality of the comments on the AAA blog, as well as the fact that they are published by professors writing in their own name. This is the first time I have seen the anthropology professoriate as a professoriate. I hope that the AAA blog become a major site in the anthropological noosphere.
Kambiz Kamrani, anthropology.net is not so happy about the decision and summarizes some criticisms.
One of the most detailed commentary can be found on the blog Open Anthropology by Maximilian Forte. After having read through over 60 comments on the AAA blog he wrote the post Empty Scholasticism at its Best on the AAA Blog. See also his comment Politics and Ethics: Anthropologists and Human Terrain Systems.
Futhermore, Forte noticed that the AAA still has job adverts for the HTS by the U.S. military (see an example). “This should be a source of embarrassment for the Executive Board of the American Anthropological Association, although thus far there is little indication of any", Forte writes.
Geostatistics and spatial analysis in biological anthropology
科学家首次拍到猩猩面对面性爱照片
Anthropologist: Investors need to understand the tribal nature of banking culture
Take care of the different national traditions of anthropology
Welcome to Anthropology, your second career
Urban anthropologist: "Recognize that people want to come to the big cities"
Anthropology 2.0: Rethinking Why and How "Information is Power."
American Anthropological Association opposes collaboration with the military
Anthropology: the great divide
My turn: Anthropology during wartime
Glossary Cultural Anthropology
A Glossary of Manitoba Prehistoric Archaeology
Anthropology Glossary
Origins and Development of Archaeology in China
Archaeological Glossary
Introduction to Cultural anthropology
Introduction to Anthropology
One Hundred Years of Physical Anthropology in China
Introduction to Physical Anthropology
what is Physical Anthropology
Contrast Cultural Anthropology, Sociology, and Social Psychology
what is Anthropology

[anthropology homepages] anthropology online,anthropology university,applied anthropology